There is 1 message totalling 26 lines in this issue.
Topics of the day:
1. Interaction between Living Death and Clone
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Date: Fri， 7 Dec 2007 19:17:01 -0700
From: Gavin Duggan
Subject: Re: Interaction between Living Death and Clone
On 05/12/2007， Richard Drijvers wrote:
> At one point I played a Living Death. When it resolved one of my friends
> noticed he had a Clone in his graveyard. Of course he would’ve loved to
> copy my Kukosho， the Evening Star when he put the Clone into play， but in
> my opinion the Clone should’ve been put into the graveyard as a state
> based effect.
You were correct here... the creatures all come into play
simultaneously (APNAP does not apply)， and the creature to copy must
be chosen "as" they are coming into play， which is before they ARE in
play to be chosen. No Dragon for him!
--
Gavin Duggan， L3 Calgary: MTGRULES-L Netrep
Please read the list protocol before posting to this list:
* http://www.invisiblejuggernaut.org/DCIJUDGEL_protocol.html
------------------------------
End of MTGRULES-L Digest - 5 Dec 2007 to 8 Dec 2007 (#2007-261)
***************************************************************
Topics of the day:
1. Interaction between Living Death and Clone
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Date: Fri， 7 Dec 2007 19:17:01 -0700
From: Gavin Duggan
Subject: Re: Interaction between Living Death and Clone
On 05/12/2007， Richard Drijvers wrote:
> At one point I played a Living Death. When it resolved one of my friends
> noticed he had a Clone in his graveyard. Of course he would’ve loved to
> copy my Kukosho， the Evening Star when he put the Clone into play， but in
> my opinion the Clone should’ve been put into the graveyard as a state
> based effect.
You were correct here... the creatures all come into play
simultaneously (APNAP does not apply)， and the creature to copy must
be chosen "as" they are coming into play， which is before they ARE in
play to be chosen. No Dragon for him!
--
Gavin Duggan， L3 Calgary: MTGRULES-L Netrep
Please read the list protocol before posting to this list:
* http://www.invisiblejuggernaut.org/DCIJUDGEL_protocol.html
------------------------------
End of MTGRULES-L Digest - 5 Dec 2007 to 8 Dec 2007 (#2007-261)
***************************************************************
コメント